You had to be there is an expression that says you had to be in a particular situation, in that particular vibe, to fully understand a situation. It could have been something that was particularly funny, but on retelling seems to fall flat, or a special emotional occasion which somehow fails to evoke the same emotional depth on relating this to others.
This tells us something that we all intuitively know – that situations are different. Indeed, in social psychology many believe this is one of the most underrated aspects of behaviour: situational or environmental influences. Consider how people behave in churches all over the world. When people walk into a church, they become quiet, and speak in whispers and walk gently around. Churches evoke this behaviour in introverts and extroverts alike. The context is more important than personality.
The contributing factors to situations and contexts are wide and diverse. But it also means that what happens in one situation may not happen in another. So, when it comes to change and behaviour, we have to be conscious of how much is driven by the situation – or indeed if it is situation dependent.
Within this is a supply side problem of people and skills – a change programme may have worked in one situation because of particularly talented individuals or leaders driving this – but you cannot copy and scale these because these are particular skills that limited individuals have.
This means we may be able to change behaviour in one situation and initiate the positive change we want to see but in another it may completely fail.
Simple Takeaways
-
- Understand situations and contexts
- Anaylse situations and contexts
- Collect data on contextual aspects
(including various personality or demographic data as already recommended) - Multiple pilots or trials (as already recommended) in different contexts
© leading brains 2022
References
More Articles
Don’t Try to Change Minds – Change Behaviour
Don’t try to change minds but simply change behaviour is the result a group of researchers have come to with regard to vaccinations.
Introduction to SCOAP
SCOAP is a complete model of human motivation, behaviour, and wellbeing, summarising over a century of research into the human brain, human psychology, and human behaviour in all contexts.
SCOAP Needs
These are basic human needs which means fulfilling them is essential for human wellbeing and therefore also that having them unfulfilled or violated lowers human wellbeing. These also direct human motivation and subsequently human behaviours.
SCOAP Motivation
Much has been written about motivation and there are many (false) assumptions to motivation also. So let’s start with a simple definition of motivation.
SCOAP Behaviour
Behaviour is about doing things, actions. That is obvious, but there are many grey zones to behaviour. For example do we class breathing as behaviour, or heartbeat, or sweating?
SCOAP Change
As you will have seen with SCOAP, this gives a comprehensive model of human needs, motivation, and behaviour. We can therefore use this to guide behavioural change interventions.
The Undermining Effect
Rewards sound like a good way to instigate behaviour you want. In our world we often think of financial rewards. Good idea, right?
Well, no, rewards can actually lower motivation.
Making Change Stick
The sustainability question, or problem, is ultimately the biggest and most important question or issue.
The Value-Action Gap
The value-action gap has multiple other names: attitude-behavior gap, intention-behavior gap, KAP-gap (knowledge-attitudes-practice gap) or belief-behavior gap.
It refers to the gap between what people often say they value and their subsequent actions or willingness to meaningfully contribute to this value.
Uncertainty Changes Behaviour (But Boiling Frogs Doesn’t)
Why do people make random and unpredictable decisions when uncertainty arises (such as buying toilet paper at the start of a pandemic)?