Article

Scalability – Voltage Drops

limitations change

Voltage Drop is a useful term and analogy to the problems of scaling ideas or change in any environment. Voltage drop refers to how electrical current can decrease across distance it travels. Obviously, something we want to avoid – so if applied to ideas or change it means that the potency of this decreases the further it travels. This would be in contrast to it magnifying or increasing like a virus – the well-known effect of going viral.

If we imagine an electrical circuit and this branching off into the distance and at each branch the current becomes weaker and as the distance increase it also becomes weaker. This is a voltage drop. The concept of voltage drop was proposed in this form by John A. List in his 2022 book The Voltage Effect.

In summary he proposes five main reasons for voltage drops and we have expanded these (to clearly separate some concepts):

  1. False positives: The inference problem
  2. Representativeness of the population
  3. Representativeness of the situation
  4. Unintended consequences and negative spillovers
  5. The supply side of scaling
  6. The Equilibrium Effect

© leading brains 2022

Reference

 

More articles on limitations to behavioural change

Introduction to SCOAP

Introduction to SCOAP

SCOAP is a complete model of human motivation, behaviour, and wellbeing, summarising over a century of research into the human brain, human psychology, and human behaviour in all contexts.

SCOAP Needs

SCOAP Needs

These are basic human needs which means fulfilling them is essential for human wellbeing and therefore also that having them unfulfilled or violated lowers human wellbeing. These also direct human motivation and subsequently human behaviours.

SCOAP Motivation

SCOAP Motivation

Much has been written about motivation and there are many (false) assumptions to motivation also. So let’s start with a simple definition of motivation.

SCOAP Behaviour

SCOAP Behaviour

Behaviour is about doing things, actions. That is obvious, but there are many grey zones to behaviour. For example do we class breathing as behaviour, or heartbeat, or sweating?

SCOAP Change

SCOAP Change

As you will have seen with SCOAP, this gives a comprehensive model of  human needs, motivation, and behaviour. We can therefore use this to guide behavioural change interventions.

The Undermining Effect

The Undermining Effect

Rewards sound like a good way to instigate behaviour you want. In our world we often think of financial rewards. Good idea, right?
Well, no, rewards can actually lower motivation.

The Value-Action Gap

The Value-Action Gap

The value-action gap has multiple other names:  attitude-behavior gap, intention-behavior gap, KAP-gap (knowledge-attitudes-practice gap) or belief-behavior gap.

It refers to the gap between what people often say they value and their subsequent actions or willingness to meaningfully contribute to this value.